← Back to 20250617

BAML ideas claude

Documentation for BAML_ideas_claude from the Ds ex repository.

Looking at both codebases, I believe taking inspiration from BAML’s compile-time approach rather than directly integrating the Elixir client would be the better choice for DSPEx. Here’s why:

Why Inspiration Over Integration

1. Architectural Philosophy Alignment

DSPEx already has a strong foundation with its signature system and teleprompter architecture. BAML’s value isn’t in its runtime client, but in its compile-time schema engineering approach - which aligns perfectly with DSPEx’s existing signature system.

2. BAML’s Core Innovation is Compile-Time

The real magic in BAML is:

  • Schema-aligned parsing (SAP) for reliable structured outputs
  • Compile-time prompt generation from schemas
  • Static prompt analysis and optimization
  • Type-safe streaming interfaces

These are compiler/macro features, not runtime client features.

3. DSPEx Already Has Superior Runtime Architecture

DSPEx already has:

  • Excellent concurrency via BEAM
  • Sophisticated teleprompter optimization
  • Foundation integration for observability
  • Multi-provider client management

Phase 1: Schema-Aligned Parsing (SAP)

Enhance DSPEx signatures with BAML-style output parsing:

defmodule ResumeExtractor do
  use DSPEx.Signature, "resume_text -> person_info"
  
  # Enhanced with BAML-style schema validation
  output_schema :person_info do
    field :name, :string, required: true
    field :skills, {:array, :string}
    field :experience, {:array, :map} do
      field :company, :string
      field :role, :string
      field :years, :integer
    end
  end
end

Phase 2: Compile-Time Prompt Optimization

Add BAML-style prompt compilation:

defmodule ChatAgent do
  use DSPEx.Signature, "messages, tone -> response"
  
  # BAML-inspired template system
  prompt_template """
  Be a {{ tone }} assistant.
  
  {{ ctx.output_format }}
  
  {% for message in messages %}
  {{ message.role }}: {{ message.content }}
  {% endfor %}
  """
  
  # Compile-time prompt analysis
  validate_prompt_safety()
  optimize_for_model(:gpt4)
end

Phase 3: Enhanced Streaming with Type Safety

Improve DSPEx streaming with BAML-style partial types:

# Current DSPEx
{:ok, result} = DSPEx.Program.forward(program, inputs)

# Enhanced with BAML-style streaming
stream = DSPEx.Program.stream(program, inputs)
for partial <- stream do
  # partial is type-safe with optional fields
  case partial do
    %{name: name} when not is_nil(name) -> 
      IO.puts("Got name: #{name}")
    %{skills: skills} when not is_nil(skills) ->
      IO.puts("Got skills: #{inspect(skills)}")
  end
end
final = stream.get_final_response()

Implementation Plan

1. Enhance DSPEx.Signature with Schema Features

defmodule DSPEx.Signature do
  defmacro __using__(signature_string) do
    quote do
      # Existing signature parsing
      
      # Add BAML-inspired schema definitions
      def output_schema(field, type, opts \\ []) do
        # Store schema metadata for validation
      end
      
      # Add SAP-style parsing
      def parse_with_schema(response_text, output_fields) do
        # Implement flexible parsing like BAML's SAP
      end
    end
  end
end

2. Add Template System

defmodule DSPEx.Templates do
  def compile_prompt(template, context) do
    # BAML-style template compilation
    # Support Jinja2-like syntax for consistency
  end
  
  def validate_template(template) do
    # Compile-time template validation
  end
end

3. Enhance Adapter with SAP

defmodule DSPEx.Adapter do
  def parse_response_with_schema(signature, response, schema) do
    # Implement schema-aligned parsing
    # Handle markdown in JSON, chain of thought, etc.
  end
end

Why This Approach is Better

  1. Leverages DSPEx’s Strengths: Keeps the excellent teleprompter system and BEAM concurrency
  2. Adds BAML’s Best Features: Schema engineering and reliable parsing
  3. Maintains Simplicity: No NIFs or complex runtime integration
  4. Incremental: Can be implemented progressively without breaking existing code
  5. Elixir-Native: Uses macros and compile-time features that feel natural in Elixir

Conclusion

Rather than integrating BAML’s Elixir client, enhance DSPEx with BAML’s core innovations:

  • Schema-aligned parsing for reliable outputs
  • Compile-time prompt optimization
  • Type-safe streaming interfaces
  • Template-based prompt engineering

This gives you the best of both worlds: DSPEx’s powerful optimization framework + BAML’s reliable output parsing, all in a clean Elixir-native implementation.