DSPEx-SIMBA Contract Implementation Summary
Status: Ready for Implementation
Priority: Critical Blocker for SIMBA Integration
Estimated Time: 2-3 days focused implementation
Problem Identified
The test modifications in your git diff revealed a fundamental issue: tests were expecting API contracts that don’t exist in the DSPEx implementation. The agent updated tests to expect certain APIs (like Program.safe_program_info/1
, Program.has_demos?/1
, enhanced forward/3
, etc.) but never implemented these APIs in the library code.
Root Cause: No formal API contract was defined between DSPEx and SIMBA, leading to assumptions about interfaces that don’t exist.
Solution Delivered
I’ve provided a comprehensive set of technical artifacts to address this:
1. API Contract Specification
Formal specification defining exactly what SIMBA needs from DSPEx, including:
- Program execution contracts (
forward/2
,forward/3
) - Program introspection contracts (
program_type/1
,safe_program_info/1
,has_demos?/1
) - Client interface stability contracts
- Configuration management contracts
- OptimizedProgram enhancement contracts
- Foundation services integration contracts
2. Implementation Roadmap
Detailed 3-day implementation plan with:
- Phase-by-phase implementation strategy
- Specific code changes required
- Risk assessment and mitigation
- Success criteria for each phase
3. Code Patches
Ready-to-apply code modifications for:
lib/dspex/program.ex
- Add missing introspection functions and enhancedforward/3
lib/dspex/optimized_program.ex
- SIMBA metadata support and native capability detectionlib/dspex/services/config_manager.ex
- SIMBA configuration paths and service conflict resolutionlib/dspex/client.ex
- Response format stabilization and error categorizationlib/dspex/teleprompter/bootstrap_fewshot.ex
- Empty demo handling fixeslib/dspex/services/telemetry_setup.ex
- SIMBA telemetry event support
4. Contract Validation Tests
Comprehensive test suite including:
test/integration/simba_contract_validation_test.exs
- Validates all SIMBA contract requirementstest/integration/simba_integration_smoke_test.exs
- End-to-end SIMBA workflow validationtest/unit/program_contract_compliance_test.exs
- Unit tests for individual contract compliance
Critical Implementation Requirements
🔴 CRITICAL BLOCKERS (Must implement before SIMBA)
- Program.forward/3 with options support (timeout, correlation_id)
- Program introspection functions (
program_type/1
,safe_program_info/1
,has_demos?/1
) - Client response format stabilization for instruction generation
- OptimizedProgram metadata support for SIMBA optimization data
- ConfigManager.get_with_default/2 for SIMBA configuration paths
🟡 HIGH PRIORITY (Implement during SIMBA integration)
- Telemetry correlation for optimization tracking
- Error categorization for predictable recovery
- Concurrent safety validation under load
- Foundation integration service lifecycle management
Expected Implementation Timeline
Day 1: Core Program Contract
- ✅ Implement
Program.forward/3
with timeout and correlation_id - ✅ Add
Program.program_type/1
,safe_program_info/1
,has_demos?/1
- ✅ Create basic contract validation tests
- ✅ Stabilize Client response format
Day 2: Service Integration
- ✅ Enhance ConfigManager for SIMBA configuration paths
- ✅ Resolve service lifecycle conflicts with Foundation
- ✅ Add SIMBA telemetry event support
- ✅ Validate OptimizedProgram metadata handling
Day 3: Completion and Validation
- ✅ Fix BootstrapFewShot empty demo handling
- ✅ Complete comprehensive contract test suite
- ✅ Run SIMBA integration smoke test
- ✅ Establish performance baselines
Implementation Strategy
Step 1: Apply Code Patches
Use the provided code patches to implement the missing contract APIs:
# Apply patches to lib files
# Implement Program contract functions
# Enhance OptimizedProgram metadata support
# Fix ConfigManager SIMBA paths
# Stabilize Client response format
# Fix Teleprompter empty demo handling
Step 2: Add Contract Validation Tests
# Add contract validation test files
cp contract_validation_tests.exs test/integration/simba_contract_validation_test.exs
cp contract_validation_tests.exs test/integration/simba_integration_smoke_test.exs
cp contract_validation_tests.exs test/unit/program_contract_compliance_test.exs
Step 3: Validate Implementation
# Run contract tests
mix test test/integration/simba_contract_validation_test.exs
mix test test/integration/simba_integration_smoke_test.exs
mix test test/unit/program_contract_compliance_test.exs
# Ensure no regressions
mix test
mix dialyzer
Success Criteria
Contract Implementation Complete When:
- ✅ All contract validation tests pass
- ✅ SIMBA integration smoke test passes
- ✅ No regressions in existing functionality
- ✅ Service integration conflicts resolved
- ✅ Performance baselines maintained
Ready for SIMBA Integration When:
- ✅ All critical blocker APIs implemented
- ✅ Error recovery patterns validated
- ✅ Concurrent execution safety confirmed
- ✅ Foundation services integrate cleanly
- ✅ Comprehensive test coverage achieved
Post-Implementation Benefits
- Formal API Contract: Clear specification of what SIMBA expects from DSPEx
- Stable Integration Surface: Well-defined APIs that won’t change unexpectedly
- Comprehensive Testing: Full validation of all integration points
- Error Recovery: Predictable error handling patterns
- Performance Baseline: Known performance characteristics for optimization
- Documentation: Clear understanding of system capabilities and limitations
Risk Mitigation
High-Risk Areas Addressed:
- Program.forward/3 - Incremental implementation with backward compatibility
- Foundation Integration - Conflict resolution for already-started services
- Concurrent Safety - Explicit testing under load conditions