← Back to Sinter

SINTER TODO

Documentation for SINTER_TODO from the Ds ex repository.

SINTER Integration TODO: Complete Elixact Migration

Status Summary

Current State: SINTER integration Phase 1 ✅ COMPLETED - Configuration validation now uses Sinter
Key Issue: ✅ RESOLVED - Configuration validation system successfully migrated to Sinter
Dependencies: Both Elixact and Sinter are active dependencies (Elixact ready for removal)
Goal: Complete migration and remove Elixact entirely - ✅ PHASE 1 DONE, READY FOR PHASE 2

Critical Issues Found

1. ✅ Config Validator Migrated to Sinter

File: lib/dspex/config/validator.ex:162
Migrated Code:

case SinterSchemas.validate_config_value(path, value) do

Status: ✅ COMPLETED - All config validation now uses Sinter

2. ❌ Dual Dependencies in mix.exs

Current:

{:elixact, github: "nshkrdotcom/elixact"},
{:sinter, github: "nshkrdotcom/sinter"},

Required: Remove Elixact dependency after migration complete

3. ❌ Old Elixact Files Still Present

  • /lib/dspex/elixact.ex (410 lines)
  • /lib/dspex/config/elixact_schemas.ex (555 lines)
  • /lib/dspex/signature/elixact.ex

TODO List

Phase 1: Complete Config Migration ✅ COMPLETED (HIGH PRIORITY)

1.1 Fix Config Validator ✅ COMPLETED

  • Update: lib/dspex/config/validator.ex:162
    # CHANGED FROM:
case ElixactSchemas.validate_config_value(path, value) do
# CHANGED TO:
case SinterSchemas.validate_config_value(path, value) do

1.2 Verify SinterSchemas API Compatibility ✅ COMPLETED

  • Check: Does SinterSchemas.validate_config_value/2 exist? ✅ YES - EXISTS
  • Implement: Function already exists in lib/dspex/config/sinter_schemas.ex
  • Test: API fully compatible, config validation tests pass ✅ 29/29 TESTS PASS

1.3 Update Remaining Config References ✅ COMPLETED

  • Search: Found all remaining ElixactSchemas references ✅ 4 REFERENCES FOUND
  • Replace: Updated all to SinterSchemas ✅ ALL UPDATED
    • alias DSPEx.Config.ElixactSchemas → alias DSPEx.Config.SinterSchemas
    • ElixactSchemas.validate_config_value/2 calls → SinterSchemas.validate_config_value/2
    • ElixactSchemas.list_domains() → SinterSchemas.list_domains()
    • ElixactSchemas.export_json_schema/1 → SinterSchemas.export_json_schema/1
  • Test: All config validation tests pass ✅ 29/29 TESTS PASS

Phase 2: Remove Elixact Dependencies

2.1 Search and Replace All Elixact References

  • Search: grep -r "Elixact\|elixact" lib/
  • Replace: All references with Sinter equivalents
  • Files to check:
    • lib/dspex/signature.ex
    • lib/dspex/config/schemas/*.ex (8 files)

2.2 Update mix.exs Dependencies

  • Remove: {:elixact, github: "nshkrdotcom/elixact"}
  • Test: mix deps.get && mix compile
  • Verify: No compilation errors

2.3 Delete Old Elixact Files

  • Remove: lib/dspex/elixact.ex
  • Remove: lib/dspex/config/elixact_schemas.ex
  • Remove: lib/dspex/signature/elixact.ex
  • Clean: Remove any elixact references from .dialyzer_ignore.exs

Phase 3: Clean Up Test Files

3.1 Remove Elixact Test Files

  • Delete: test/unit/elixact/compatibility_test.exs
  • Delete: test/unit/config_elixact_schemas_test.exs
  • Delete: test/unit/signature_elixact_test.exs
  • Delete: test/unit/signature/elixact_enhanced_test.exs
  • Delete: test/integration/elixact_integration_test.exs
  • Delete: test/integration/simba_elixact_integration_test.exs

3.2 Update Remaining Test References

  • Update: test/performance/elixact_vs_baseline_test.exs (rename to sinter_vs_baseline)
  • Clean: Remove elixact references from other test files

Phase 4: Verification and Testing

4.1 Comprehensive Test Suite

  • Run: mix test - All tests must pass
  • Run: mix dialyzer - Zero warnings
  • Run: mix credo --strict - Clean code quality

4.2 Dependency Verification

  • Check: mix deps.tree shows no elixact dependency
  • Check: mix deps.unlock --check-unused shows clean deps
  • Verify: Application still compiles and runs correctly

4.3 Functionality Testing

  • Test: Configuration validation works with Sinter
  • Test: SIMBA optimization still works
  • Test: Signature system works with Sinter only
  • Test: All integration tests pass

Phase 5: Documentation Update

5.1 Update Integration Documentation

  • Fix: SINTER_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md - Remove false “COMPLETED” claims
  • Update: Status to reflect actual completion
  • Document: Remaining work and blockers

5.2 Update Main Documentation

  • Remove: All Elixact references from README
  • Update: Examples to use Sinter only
  • Clean: Remove migration documentation once complete

Implementation Order

Step 1: Critical Config Fix ⚠️ DO FIRST

  1. Check if SinterSchemas.validate_config_value/2 exists
  2. If missing, implement it in lib/dspex/config/sinter_schemas.ex
  3. Update lib/dspex/config/validator.ex:162 to use SinterSchemas
  4. Test config validation works

Step 2: Systematic Replacement

  1. Run comprehensive search for Elixact references
  2. Replace all with Sinter equivalents
  3. Test each change incrementally

Step 3: Dependency Cleanup

  1. Remove Elixact from mix.exs
  2. Delete old Elixact files
  3. Clean up test files

Step 4: Final Verification

  1. Full test suite
  2. Compilation verification
  3. Functionality testing

Risk Assessment

Low Risk:

  • Sinter implementation is complete and tested
  • Most integration already working
  • Clear migration path exists

Medium Risk:

  • Config validation system is critical - must work correctly
  • Need to ensure API compatibility between Elixact and Sinter schemas

Mitigation:

  • Test each change incrementally
  • Keep backup of working state
  • Verify functionality at each step

Success Criteria

  • ✅ All tests pass with Sinter only
  • ✅ No Elixact dependencies in mix.exs
  • ✅ No Elixact files in codebase
  • ✅ Configuration validation works correctly
  • ✅ SIMBA optimization functions normally
  • ✅ Clean dialyzer and credo results
  • ✅ Documentation reflects actual state

Estimated Completion Time

Total: 4-6 hours of focused work

  • Phase 1 (Config Fix): 1-2 hours
  • Phase 2 (Elixact Removal): 1-2 hours
  • Phase 3 (Test Cleanup): 1 hour
  • Phase 4 (Verification): 1 hour
  • Phase 5 (Documentation): 30 minutes

Next Actions

  1. IMMEDIATE: Check if SinterSchemas.validate_config_value/2 exists
  2. IF MISSING: Implement the function
  3. THEN: Update config validator to use Sinter
  4. TEST: Verify config validation works
  5. CONTINUE: Systematic Elixact removal

Bottom Line: The SINTER integration is well-implemented but needs the config validator updated and Elixact dependencies removed to be truly complete. This is achievable in a few hours of focused work.