← Back to Phase1 CF

GAP STEPS

Documentation for GAP_STEPS from the Ds ex repository.

ElixirML Foundation - Gap Analysis & Implementation Steps

Executive Summary

After comprehensive analysis of the ElixirML foundation implementation versus documented requirements from ELIXIR_API_REVISED.md, GAP_0001.md, GAP_0002.md, docs_variable/.md, and Phase1_CF/.md, the implementation is 95% complete with excellent architecture and test coverage. However, there are critical integration gaps between the foundation and the main DSPEx system that need to be addressed.

Current Implementation Status

✅ FULLY IMPLEMENTED - Foundation Components (95%+)

Schema Engine - COMPLETE ✅

  • All 7 core components implemented and tested (18 tests passing)
  • ML-specific types (embedding, probability, confidence_score, etc.)
  • Compile-time optimization with runtime flexibility
  • Comprehensive validation with detailed error reporting

Variable System - COMPLETE ✅

  • Universal variable abstraction (float, integer, choice, module, composite)
  • ML-specific variables (provider, model, adapter, reasoning_strategy)
  • Variable space management with constraints and dependencies
  • 29 tests including property-based testing with StreamData

Resource Framework - COMPLETE ✅

  • Ash-inspired declarative resource management
  • Complete CRUD operations with relationships
  • 6 concrete resources (Program, OptimizationRun, VariableSpace, etc.)
  • 36 tests covering all resource operations

Process Orchestrator - COMPLETE ✅

  • Advanced supervision tree with 10 child processes
  • Pipeline execution (sequential, parallel, DAG strategies)
  • High-performance caching with LRU eviction
  • 23 tests covering fault tolerance and execution

❌ CRITICAL GAPS - Main System Integration

The foundation is excellent but disconnected from main DSPEx:

  1. DSPEx Program Integration - 0% implemented
  2. DSPEx Signature Enhancement - 0% implemented
  3. DSPEx Teleprompter Integration - 0% implemented
  4. Variable-Aware Optimization - 0% implemented
  5. Schema-DSPEx Integration - 0% implemented

Gap Analysis by Priority

🔥 CRITICAL GAPS - Week 1 Priority

Gap 1: DSPEx Program-Variable Integration

Status: Foundation exists, DSPEx integration missing Impact: Users cannot access Variable System through DSPEx API Files to Create/Modify:

  • Enhance lib/dspex/program.ex with ElixirML.Variable integration
  • Create variable extraction from DSPEx signatures
  • Add automatic variable space generation

Gap 2: DSPEx Signature-Schema Integration

Status: Schema Engine complete, DSPEx.Signature not enhanced Impact: No ML-specific validation in DSPEx workflows Files to Create/Modify:

  • Enhance lib/dspex/signature.ex with ElixirML.Schema
  • Add ML-type validation to signature parsing
  • Create schema-based signature validation

Gap 3: Main DSPEx API Enhancement

Status: Foundation complete, main API unchanged Impact: Users access old DSPEx API without new capabilities Files to Create/Modify:

  • Enhance lib/dspex.ex main entry point
  • Add variable-aware program creation
  • Integrate schema validation in API

🚨 HIGH PRIORITY GAPS - Week 2

Gap 4: SIMBA-Variable Integration

Status: Process Orchestrator ready, SIMBA not variable-aware Impact: No automatic parameter optimization Files to Create/Modify:

  • Enhance lib/dspex/teleprompter/simba.ex with Variable System
  • Add multi-objective evaluation using Process.EvaluationWorkers
  • Implement configuration sampling and optimization

Gap 5: Client-Provider Integration

Status: Process.ClientPool exists, not integrated with DSPEx Impact: No automatic provider selection and cost optimization Files to Create/Modify:

  • Enhance lib/dspex/client.ex with Process.ClientPool
  • Add provider-model compatibility validation
  • Integrate ML-specific variables (provider, model, adapter)

Gap 6: Missing Variable Types from Elixact Spec

Status: Core types implemented, Elixact-specific types missing Impact: Not fully compliant with Elixact API specification Files to Create/Modify:

  • Add :hybrid and :conditional variable types to Variable System
  • Implement multi-objective evaluation framework
  • Add Pareto frontier analysis

📋 MEDIUM PRIORITY GAPS - Week 3

Gap 7: Advanced Schema-Variable Integration

Status: Basic integration exists, advanced features missing Impact: Cannot auto-generate schemas from variable configurations Enhancement Needed:

  • Variable-aware schema generation
  • Conditional field validation based on variable values
  • Dynamic schema templates

Gap 8: Advanced Process Features

Status: Basic orchestration complete, advanced features partial Impact: Some documented features not fully implemented Enhancement Needed:

  • DAG execution strategy (currently falls back to sequential)
  • Advanced retry mechanisms with exponential backoff
  • Distributed process coordination

Gap 9: Performance Optimizations

Status: Good performance, optimization opportunities exist Impact: Could be faster for large-scale optimization Enhancement Needed:

  • Parallel configuration evaluation
  • Intelligent caching for variable evaluations
  • Early stopping for constraint violations

🔧 LOW PRIORITY GAPS - Week 4

Gap 10: Documentation and Examples

Status: Foundation documented, usage examples missing Impact: Developer onboarding and adoption challenges Enhancement Needed:

  • End-to-end usage examples combining all foundation components
  • Migration guide from old DSPEx to enhanced version
  • Performance tuning guidelines

Gap 11: External Tool Integration

Status: Tool registry exists, specific tools missing Impact: Limited ecosystem integration Enhancement Needed:

  • Jido integration patterns
  • External optimizer adapters
  • Third-party ML tool integration

Implementation Steps (Prioritized)

STEP 1: DSPEx Program-Variable Integration (Week 1, Days 1-2)

Goal: Enable variable declaration and management in DSPEx programs

Tasks:

  1. Enhance DSPEx.Program (lib/dspex/program.ex)

    • Add use ElixirML.Resource
    • Include :variable_space field in program struct
    • Add variable/3 macro for declaring variables in programs
    • Implement variable resolution in forward/3

  2. Create Program.Variable Helper (lib/dspex/program/variable.ex)

    • Variable extraction from signatures and configurations
    • Automatic ML variable additions (provider, adapter, etc.)
    • Variable space validation and configuration

  3. Update Tests (test/dspex/program_test.exs)

    • Test variable declaration and resolution
    • Test integration with existing program functionality
    • Test variable space management

Success Criteria:

# This should work after Step 1
program = DSPEx.Program.new(signature)
|> DSPEx.Program.variable(:temperature, :float, range: {0.0, 2.0})
|> DSPEx.Program.variable(:provider, :choice, choices: [:openai, :anthropic])

{:ok, result} = DSPEx.forward(program, inputs, variables: %{temperature: 0.8})

STEP 2: DSPEx Signature-Schema Integration (Week 1, Days 3-4)

Goal: Add ML-specific validation to DSPEx signatures

Tasks:

  1. Enhance DSPEx.Signature (lib/dspex/signature.ex)

    • Add use ElixirML.Schema support
    • Include ML-specific field types in signature parsing
    • Add schema validation to signature processing

  2. Create Signature Schema DSL (lib/dspex/signature/schema.ex)

    • ML-aware field definitions (embedding, confidence_score, etc.)
    • Automatic variable extraction from schema fields
    • Integration with existing signature parser

  3. Update Signature Tests (test/dspex/signature_test.exs)

    • Test ML-type validation in signatures
    • Test schema integration functionality
    • Test variable extraction from signatures

Success Criteria:

# This should work after Step 2
defmodule MySignature do
  use DSPEx.Signature
  
  input :question, :string
  input :context, :embedding, dimensions: 1536
  output :answer, :string  
  output :confidence, :confidence_score
end

STEP 3: Main DSPEx API Integration (Week 1, Days 5-7)

Goal: Expose enhanced capabilities through main DSPEx API

Tasks:

  1. Enhance Main DSPEx Module (lib/dspex.ex)

    • Add variable-aware program/2 function
    • Include schema validation in main workflows
    • Integrate Process Orchestrator for execution

  2. Create Enhanced Program Builder (lib/dspex/builder.ex)

    • Fluent API for program configuration with variables
    • Automatic ML variable additions
    • Schema-based validation

  3. Update Main API Tests (test/dspex_test.exs)

    • Test enhanced API functionality
    • Test integration with all foundation components
    • Test backward compatibility

Success Criteria:

# This should work after Step 3
program = DSPEx.program(MySignature)
|> DSPEx.with_variables(%{provider: :openai, temperature: 0.7})
|> DSPEx.with_schema_validation(true)

{:ok, result} = DSPEx.forward(program, inputs)

STEP 4: SIMBA-Variable Integration (Week 2, Days 1-3)

Goal: Enable automatic parameter optimization in SIMBA

Tasks:

  1. Enhance SIMBA Teleprompter (lib/dspex/teleprompter/simba.ex)

    • Add variable space detection and optimization
    • Implement configuration sampling using Variable.Space
    • Add multi-objective evaluation framework

  2. Create Variable-Aware Evaluation (lib/dspex/teleprompter/evaluation.ex)

    • Multi-criteria evaluation (accuracy, cost, latency)
    • Configuration ranking and selection
    • Integration with Process.EvaluationWorkers

  3. Update SIMBA Tests (test/dspex/teleprompter/simba_test.exs)

    • Test variable optimization functionality
    • Test multi-objective evaluation
    • Test integration with Variable System

Success Criteria:

# This should work after Step 4
optimized = DSPEx.optimize(program, training_data, 
  variables: [:provider, :temperature, :reasoning_strategy],
  objectives: [:accuracy, :cost, :latency]
)

STEP 5: Client-Provider Integration (Week 2, Days 4-5)

Goal: Integrate provider selection with client management

Tasks:

  1. Enhance DSPEx.Client (lib/dspex/client.ex)

    • Integration with Process.ClientPool
    • Provider-model compatibility validation
    • Automatic client selection based on variables

  2. Create Provider Management (lib/dspex/provider.ex)

    • Provider registry and capability detection
    • Cost and performance tracking
    • Compatibility matrix management

  3. Update Client Tests (test/dspex/client_test.exs)

    • Test provider selection and management
    • Test compatibility validation
    • Test integration with Process.ClientPool

STEP 6: Missing Variable Types (Week 2, Days 6-7)

Goal: Add missing Elixact API compliance features

Tasks:

  1. Add Hybrid Variables (lib/elixir_ml/variable.ex)

    • Implement :hybrid variable type
    • Add choice-range mapping functionality
    • Update Variable.Space validation

  2. Add Conditional Variables (lib/elixir_ml/variable.ex)

    • Implement :conditional variable type
    • Add condition evaluation logic
    • Update constraint validation

  3. Add Multi-Objective Framework (lib/elixir_ml/evaluation/)

    • Pareto frontier analysis
    • Multi-objective optimization algorithms
    • Objective weight management

STEP 7: Advanced Integration Features (Week 3)

Goal: Complete advanced integration between foundation components

STEP 8: Performance Optimizations (Week 3-4)

Goal: Optimize performance for production workloads

STEP 9: Documentation and Examples (Week 4)

Goal: Complete developer experience with examples and guides

Testing Strategy

Integration Testing Priority

  1. DSPEx-Foundation Integration: Ensure all DSPEx modules work with foundation
  2. End-to-End Workflows: Complete optimization workflows from program to result
  3. Performance Validation: Benchmark enhanced system vs original
  4. Backward Compatibility: Ensure existing DSPEx code continues to work

Test Coverage Goals

  • Integration Tests: 95%+ coverage of DSPEx-Foundation integration
  • End-to-End Tests: All documented workflows working
  • Performance Tests: Benchmarks for all critical paths
  • Property Tests: Variable generation and optimization edge cases

Success Metrics

Functional Success

  • Foundation components working (95% complete)
  • DSPEx integration complete (0% complete)
  • End-to-end optimization workflows (0% complete)
  • Elixact API compliance (70% complete)

Performance Success

  • Sub-millisecond schema validation (✅ achieved)
  • Variable optimization <20% overhead vs manual (❌ not measured)
  • Multi-objective evaluation <5s for 100 configurations (❌ not implemented)

Developer Success

  • Converting programs to use variables <5 lines (❌ not possible yet)
  • Automatic optimization discovery working (❌ not integrated)
  • Complete documentation and examples (❌ missing)

Conclusion

The ElixirML foundation is architecturally excellent and nearly complete, but requires critical integration work to bridge the gap between the foundation and the main DSPEx system. The implementation steps above prioritize this integration work to deliver the promised revolutionary capabilities to end users.

Priority Focus: Steps 1-3 are critical for basic functionality. Steps 4-6 unlock the advanced optimization capabilities. Steps 7-9 complete the system for production use.

Analysis Date: 2025-06-20
Foundation Status: 95% Complete
Integration Status: 5% Complete
Next Priority: DSPEx Program-Variable Integration