← Back to Foundation

LIB OLD list

Documentation for LIB_OLD_list from the Foundation repository.

LIB_OLD Missing Infrastructure Analysis

Executive Summary

Analysis of current Foundation/JidoSystem implementation vs lib_old reveals significant infrastructure gaps. Current system has basic Foundation protocols and Jido integration, but lacks production-grade infrastructure services that existed in lib_old. This document focuses on infrastructure and service layer components needed to support robust Jido agent operations.

Current Infrastructure State

✅ What We Have (Current lib/)

  • Basic Foundation protocols (Registry, Infrastructure, Coordination)
  • JidoSystem agents (TaskAgent, MonitorAgent, CoordinatorAgent, FoundationAgent)
  • Simple circuit breaker using :fuse library
  • Basic ETS-based caching with TTL
  • Resource manager with memory/ETS monitoring
  • Basic telemetry wrapper around :telemetry
  • Error handling with hierarchical error codes
  • Jido integration layer (Bridge, SignalRouter)

❌ Critical Infrastructure Missing from lib_old

1. Advanced Infrastructure Services (HIGH PRIORITY)

1.1 Connection Management

lib_old had: Foundation.Infrastructure.ConnectionManager

  • Connection pooling for external services
  • HTTP connection management with PoolWorkers.HttpWorker
  • Connection health monitoring and automatic recovery
  • Connection pool sizing and lifecycle management

Current gap: JidoSystem agents make external calls with no connection pooling

1.2 Rate Limiting

lib_old had: Foundation.Infrastructure.RateLimiter

  • Rate limiting with Hammer backend
  • Per-service rate limit configuration
  • Sliding window and token bucket algorithms
  • Rate limit status monitoring and alerts

Current gap: No protection against API rate limits or resource exhaustion

1.3 Advanced Circuit Breaker

lib_old had: More sophisticated circuit breaker with:

  • Multiple failure thresholds (network, timeout, application errors)
  • Half-open state with gradual recovery
  • Circuit breaker metrics and dashboards
  • Per-service configuration with fallback strategies

Current gap: Basic :fuse implementation missing advanced features

2. Service Layer Architecture (HIGH PRIORITY)

2.1 Service Discovery and Registration

lib_old had: Foundation.Services.ServiceBehaviour and Foundation.ServiceRegistry

  • Automatic service discovery within cluster
  • Service health checking and heartbeat monitoring
  • Service capability registration and matching
  • Load balancing across service instances

Current gap: JidoSystem agents manually register, no dynamic discovery

2.2 Configuration Service

lib_old had: Foundation.Services.ConfigServer

  • Centralized configuration management
  • Hot-reload of configuration without restart
  • Configuration versioning and rollback
  • Environment-specific configuration with fallbacks
  • Configuration validation and schema enforcement

Current gap: Each agent manages own config, no central management

2.3 Event Store Service

lib_old had: Foundation.Services.EventStore

  • Event persistence and querying system
  • Event replay capabilities for debugging
  • Event streaming with backpressure
  • Event schema evolution and migration

Current gap: No persistent event storage for agent coordination

2.4 Telemetry Service

lib_old had: Foundation.Services.TelemetryService

  • Centralized metrics collection and aggregation
  • Custom metrics with labels and dimensions
  • Metric retention policies and storage
  • Alert rules and notification routing
  • Performance baseline tracking

Current gap: Basic telemetry emission, no centralized collection

3. Retry and Resilience Infrastructure (HIGH PRIORITY)

3.1 Advanced Retry Mechanisms

lib_old had: Sophisticated retry with:

  • Multiple retry strategies (exponential backoff, fixed delay, jitter)
  • Circuit breaker integration for retry decisions
  • Retry budget tracking to prevent retry storms
  • Dead letter queue for permanently failed operations
  • Retry metrics and observability

Current gap: Agent error handling mentions retry but no implementation

3.2 ElixirRetry Integration

Missing: Integration with https://github.com/safwank/ElixirRetry

  • Declarative retry policies with DSL
  • Conditional retry based on error types
  • Retry with delay patterns and jitter
  • Maximum retry attempts with timeout

Needed for: TaskAgent task processing, CoordinatorAgent workflow execution

4. Storage and Persistence Layer (MEDIUM PRIORITY)

4.1 Process Registry with Persistence

lib_old had: Foundation.ProcessRegistry with advanced features:

  • Registry persistence across node restarts
  • Registry partitioning for scalability
  • Registry backup and restore capabilities
  • Registry migration between nodes
  • Registry monitoring and health checks

Current gap: Basic ETS registry, no persistence

4.2 Persistent Queue System

lib_old had: Persistent queues with:

  • Durable task queues that survive restarts
  • Queue partitioning and sharding
  • Queue monitoring and metrics
  • Dead letter queue handling
  • Queue priority and scheduling

Current gap: TaskAgent queue is in-memory only

5. Monitoring and Observability (MEDIUM PRIORITY)

5.1 Performance Monitor

lib_old had: Foundation.PerformanceMonitor with:

  • Application-level performance metrics
  • Resource usage trending and forecasting
  • Performance alerting with thresholds
  • Automated performance issue detection
  • Performance regression tracking

Current gap: Basic resource monitoring, no performance analysis

5.2 Health Check System

lib_old had: Comprehensive health checking:

  • Multi-level health checks (service, dependency, infrastructure)
  • Health check aggregation and scoring
  • Health check scheduling and routing
  • Health check result caching and history

Current gap: Basic agent health monitoring only

5.3 Distributed Tracing

lib_old had: Request tracing across services:

  • Trace context propagation
  • Distributed trace collection
  • Trace visualization and analysis
  • Performance bottleneck identification

Current gap: No distributed tracing capabilities

6. Event and Business Logic Layer (MEDIUM PRIORITY)

6.1 Event Processing System

lib_old had: Foundation.Events and Foundation.Logic.EventLogic

  • Event modeling with schemas and validation
  • Event routing and transformation pipelines
  • Event processing with backpressure control
  • Event aggregation and materialized views

Current gap: Basic signal routing, no event processing

6.2 Validation Framework

lib_old had: Foundation.Validation.* modules:

  • Comprehensive validation framework beyond error handling
  • Configuration validation with detailed error reporting
  • Event validation with schema evolution
  • Validation rule composition and reuse

Current gap: Basic parameter validation in agents

7. Integration and Development Tools (LOW PRIORITY)

7.1 Development Endpoints

lib_old had: Foundation.TidewaveEndpoint

  • Development monitoring dashboard
  • Real-time metrics visualization
  • Configuration management interface
  • Service debugging tools

Current gap: No development dashboard

7.2 External Service Adapters

lib_old had: Foundation.Integrations.*

  • Standardized external service integration patterns
  • Service adapter framework with fallbacks
  • Service mock/stub system for testing
  • Service authentication and authorization

Current gap: No external service integration framework

Agent-Specific Infrastructure Needs

TaskAgent Requirements

  1. Circuit Breaker: References circuit_breaker_state but no implementation
  2. Retry Logic: Needs exponential backoff for task processing failures
  3. Persistent Queue: Task queue should survive restarts
  4. Dead Letter Queue: Failed tasks need permanent storage
  5. Load Balancing: Multiple TaskAgent instances need coordination

MonitorAgent Requirements

  1. Alerting Service: Alert generation exists but no delivery mechanism
  2. Metrics Storage: Historical metrics need persistent storage
  3. Threshold Management: Dynamic threshold configuration needed
  4. Alert Escalation: Notification routing and escalation workflows

CoordinatorAgent Requirements

  1. Service Discovery: Automatic agent discovery for delegation
  2. Workflow Persistence: Workflow state should survive restarts
  3. Distributed Coordination: Cluster-wide workflow coordination
  4. Result Aggregation: Sophisticated result collection and processing

FoundationAgent Requirements

  1. Health Checks: Periodic health reporting to monitoring systems
  2. Configuration Management: Centralized configuration updates
  3. Service Registration: Dynamic service registration and discovery

Implementation Priority

Phase 1: Core Infrastructure (Weeks 1-2)

  1. ElixirRetry Integration - Add declarative retry policies
  2. Enhanced Circuit Breaker - Upgrade to production-grade implementation
  3. Connection Manager - HTTP connection pooling for external services
  4. Rate Limiter - API rate limiting and resource protection

Phase 2: Service Layer (Weeks 3-4)

  1. Configuration Service - Centralized configuration management
  2. Service Discovery - Dynamic service registration and discovery
  3. Enhanced Telemetry - Centralized metrics collection and storage
  4. Persistent Storage - Task queues and workflow persistence

Phase 3: Monitoring Enhancement (Weeks 5-6)

  1. Alerting Service - Notification delivery and escalation
  2. Performance Monitor - Advanced performance tracking
  3. Health Check System - Comprehensive health monitoring
  4. Event Store - Persistent event storage and replay

Phase 4: Advanced Features (Weeks 7-8)

  1. Distributed Coordination - Cluster-wide agent coordination
  2. Load Balancing - Sophisticated load balancing algorithms
  3. Distributed Tracing - Request tracing across services
  4. Development Tools - Monitoring dashboard and debugging tools

Success Metrics

  • TaskAgent can process tasks with automatic retry and circuit breaker protection
  • MonitorAgent can deliver alerts through notification system
  • CoordinatorAgent can discover and coordinate agents dynamically
  • All agents can be configured centrally and update configuration at runtime
  • System maintains task and workflow state across restarts
  • Comprehensive observability with metrics, alerts, and tracing

Architectural Principles

  1. Foundation-Centric: All infrastructure services live in Foundation layer
  2. Jido-Compatible: Services integrate seamlessly with Jido agent patterns
  3. Protocol-Based: Use Foundation protocols for swappable implementations
  4. Production-Ready: Services should be robust enough for production use
  5. Incremental: Each service should be independently useful

This infrastructure buildout will transform the current basic Jido integration into a production-grade multi-agent system with robust error handling, monitoring, and coordination capabilities.